At the time of this post, Lock 8 Partners works closely with 11 portfolio companies. Last week, we picked our heads up to realize that four of those portfolio companies are actively seeking to hire Marketing leaders into their organizations. All at once? That’s a lot! Why the sudden glut; and what exactly is going on here? This situation and these questions prompted introspection among our team and ultimately led to the following two-part post.
The first part shares our observations about how AI is rapidly transforming Marketing roles in sub-scale B2B SaaS businesses and what that means for small teams with big ambitions.
The second part offers an outline to help answer the most important questions operators face every day: What now? What next?
I hope this resonates and helps others to gain more measured control in a world that is moving ever faster every day.
Part I – Diagnosis: The Marketing Barbell
I’ve had some version of the same conversation a dozen times over the past year, with CEOs and marketing leaders at businesses that look a lot alike: solid B2B SaaS, paying customers, real retention, but without a marketing motion that meaningfully supports accelerated growth.
At some point, we inspect recent marketing production. It’s impressive:
Twenty-two blog posts. Three personas. A brand voice guide. Nine ad variations. A five-touch nurture sequence. A competitive battlecard. Most of it was created over a long weekend, by one person, with help from their favorite AI tool, for roughly the cost of a decent lunch.
Then comes the question: “So why isn’t this working?“
It’s a fair question. Our answer is generally consistent: the work was automated before doing the hard thinking (beforehand) or cross-functional socializing (afterward). The marketer produced the execution layer of a strategy that had neither been fully agreed upon nor written down.
To be clear, I am not criticizing anyone here. I’ve made lots of my own mistakes on this front (some greatest hits are catalogued here). Nor am I pooh-poohing the new technology. AI is the most useful thing to happen to sub-scale marketing in my 25-plus years around these businesses. It fundamentally changes what a tiny marketing team can produce. Full stop.
But it changes VOLUME. It does not change DIRECTION. And in a small-scale SaaS business, direction has always been the scarce resource. That distinction matters more now than it did three years ago. Here’s why:
Capacity was never the real constraint. Every one of our portfolio companies is resource-constrained. That’s the model, the reality. We buy good businesses that are under-capitalized, and we get to work. Historically, the binding constraint on marketing in those businesses was capacity. Before investment from Lock 8, there was typically one generalist marketer (or a founder moonlighting as one, or a cast of agencies). In this situation, the business simply could not produce enough content, collateral, campaigns, and tests to move the needle.
AI has, pretty much, solved that. A competent operator with good tooling can now produce at a level that would have required a five-person team and an agency retainer three years ago. That’s not hype; and it isn’t even newsworthy. We all watch it happen every month.
But what is worth pausing to consider is the limitations of this newfound capacity. Some experts have compared AI-for-marketing to hiring an intern. An infinitely fast, infinitely willing junior marketer who works nights and weekends, never pushes back on scope, never gets bored, never asks for a title bump, and costs less per month than video conferencing software.
Hand that person a brief and they will execute it faithfully, immediately, and at whatever volume is requested. What they will never do, not once, not ever, is look up from the desk and ask the question a good marketer always asks: who is this actually for?
That’s the whole trade. And in our world, the flaws in the brief are overwhelmingly the same ones:
- The ideal customer is not defined clearly enough to separate good-fit prospects from bad-fit.
- The positioning is a price-and-speed claim. (“We’re affordable and we can get you set up quickly.” I have heard this, nearly verbatim, countless times. It is not positioning; it’s expected. And it elicits a shrug.)
- There is no evidence-based persona documentation, so every asset is aimed at a composite human who does not actually exist in the real world.
- There are proof points (real, quantified, from real customers), but they sit in three people’s heads and zero shared libraries.
- It is onerous (and debatable) to identify which channel produced the last ten customers.
Pointing an AI at that set of inputs is how we end up with twenty-two blog posts aimed at nobody, optimized for nothing, measured by no one. Faster. Cheaper. Without progress.
Marketing is barbelling, and the middle is being repriced. There’s a framing making the rounds that is worth understanding before hiring more marketers.
Marketing is splitting into a barbell. On one end sit Systems Thinkers: people who understand where data comes from, how it moves, who owns it, how a lifecycle gets instrumented, what a test has to look like to actually tell us something, and how any of it connects to revenue. On the other end sit the Storytellers: arbiters of positioning, narrative, taste, the ability to say the thing that makes a skeptical buyer stop scrolling and think, “Finally, someone gets it. Gets ME.”
In the middle sits the bar that connects the two. And the bar is Production, Execution, and Analysis: formatting the asset, drafting the third variant, building the deck, pulling the report, writing the meta description. That work hasn’t gone away. It’s been assumed by AI. And…it’s being repriced toward zero.
This has many implications, one of which is specific to companies of our portcos’ size: at ~$5M in ARR, the same person has to hold both ends of the bar. Budgets in organizations of this size don’t offer the luxury of staffing Systems Thinkers AND Storytellers. We get one human. That is a genuinely hard hiring profile, and pretending otherwise is how marketing teams end up on their fourth agency in three years.
The specialist era is over. Hubspot’s Kipp Bodnar and Kieran Flanagan devoted a recent episode of their Marketing Against the Grain podcast to a common question they often hear: is the CMO role dying? They cite roughly a ten-point decline in B2B CMO roles, and note that software companies are increasingly splitting the function apart (brand into Product Management, demand into Sales) after being disappointed by leaders who did one well and the other badly.
Their diagnosis is uncomfortable, but it resonates. The last two decades pushed marketers toward extreme specialization: be the best in the world at demand gen or product marketing, and that’s the ticket to the top job. Meanwhile, marketing roles (at least in sub-scale B2B SaaS) moved the other way, toward breadth. The job got harder and broader at exactly the moment the industry finished training a generation to go narrower. Meanwhile, because every early-stage CEO today can use an LLM to create their own marketing content, the bar for marketers has gone up FAST.
So…in terms of hiring marketing talent, what’s a small-scale SaaS business to do? Our observations/guidance fall into the “boring-but-important” bucket:
- We’re probably not hiring a CMO, and that’s fine. Businesses at $3–10M ARR need one excellent generalist with judgment, willingness to experiment, and AI fluency. Not a title or past experience with a massive remit.
- Avoid lowering the bar under time pressure. It’s tempting to “fill the seat,” particularly in the face of looming growth goals. But the right-fit person later is always better than the wrong-fit person sooner.
- Pair that generalist with a mentor who has done the part they haven’t. Inevitably, the marketer’s strengths will lean toward one side of the barbell. Really support them with resources on the other side of the barbell.
- Weight mindset over résumé. Experience is the least predictive thing we’re screening for. Paradoxically, it’s also the easiest to screen for, which is exactly why we all tend to over-index on it.
To summarize: We already have the tireless intern; that person arrived the day we bought the subscription. What is critical now is to hire the person who pushes back on the brief, who looks at the campaign everyone is excited about and says I don’t think we’ve earned the right to run this yet.
Capacity is solved. Direction isn’t.
Which raises the obvious question: what does “fix the brief” actually mean, concretely, on a Monday morning? That’s Part 2.
Thank you: I’d like to acknowledge and thank Mike McMahan, VP Performance Marketing, at Lock 8, for his thoughtful contributions to this post. Mike has a clear, disciplined, and proven approach to all things demand generation; and his thoughts shaped much of this post.